Did you know that closed elliptical orbits are possible only for the gravitational force law and the harmonic oscillator?
If gravity fell off with distance cubed, circular orbits would be unstable. (click to enlarge)

Newton first determined that gravity weakens as the inverse square of the distance. What would happen if gravity obeyed a different force law? It is an amazing fact that almost any other force law leads to orbits that do not "close" or come back to the places that they started with the original velocities. In fact only gravity (force proportional to inverse distance squared) and the harmonic oscillator (force proportional to distance) lead to closed orbits for all initial conditions. Furthermore, although all central forces allow circular orbits, these orbit are not always stable (see figure). You can explore different orbits and different force laws yourself with the Central Force Integrator.



Return to the Astronomy Workshop



Return to the Astronomy Workshop